{"id":183,"date":"2010-02-28T17:02:49","date_gmt":"2010-03-01T00:02:49","guid":{"rendered":"http:\/\/amandafrench.net\/villanelle\/?page_id=183"},"modified":"2014-02-03T01:28:20","modified_gmt":"2014-02-03T01:28:20","slug":"dylan-thomas-the-death-of-the-kings-canary","status":"publish","type":"page","link":"https:\/\/villanelle.amandafrench.net\/?page_id=183","title":{"rendered":"Dylan Thomas: The Death of the King&#8217;s Canary"},"content":{"rendered":"<p>Dylan Thomas&#8217;s first villanelle&#8211;his only other villanelle besides &#8220;Do not go gentle into that good night&#8221;&#8211;was a parody of William Empson titled &#8220;Request to Leda,&#8221; composed for a novel titled <em>The Death of the King&#8217;s Canary<\/em>. Like Auden and Empson, Thomas and Empson were friends; in 1936 the twenty-one-year-old Thomas was having &#8220;Nights Out&#8221; with &#8220;old Bill Empson,&#8221; who was a dozen years older than he was, and who had just given his poetry a rave review (Thomas, <em>Letters<\/em> 222). Friendship and favorable criticism, however, did not deter Thomas from parodying Empson&#8217;s poetry, just as it had not deterred Empson from poking fun at Auden. Friendly rivalries, debates, satires, and even insults were a hallmark of the mid-century poetic culture, and much of this signifying was done in print.<\/p>\n<p>In a 1938 letter Thomas characterized the poets of his generation as &#8220;New-Versers, intellectual muckpots leaning on a theory, post-surrealists and orgasmists, tit-in-the-night whistlers and Barkers, Empson leaning over his teeth to stare down an ice-cold throat at the mathematical mystery of his doom-treading boots, Grigson leaning over his rackets to look at his balls, Cameron riding on the back of neat graves&#8221; (<em>Letters<\/em> 311). In 1940, he was at work on a book that would flesh out these judgments at length. Thomas began collaborating in that year with his friend John Davenport on <em>The Death of the King&#8217;s Canary<\/em>, a mock-detective novel satirizing modern British poetry and poets. Thomas had originally conceived of the novel several years earlier, and had had two previous collaborators before Davenport, but the whole manuscript would not be finished until 1941. The book, which might well have laid Thomas and Davenport open to legal action, remained unpublished until 1976.<\/p>\n<p>Several modern poets, including Thomas himself, are caricatured in the narrative of <em>The Death of the King&#8217;s Canary<\/em>, but it is the first chapter that contains the core of the humor: the verse parodies. The novel begins with a harassed Prime Minister suddenly saddled with the task of choosing a new Poet Laureate (hence the &#8220;King&#8217;s Canary&#8221;). The Prime Minister, who &#8220;did not read much English poetry later than Pope, although he admired Tennyson&#8217;s ear,&#8221; is a typically unimaginative and hidebound member of the English gentry&#8211;but the modern poetry he is suddenly required to read looks even more foolish than he does (2). Author by author, school by school, Thomas and Davenport send up the contemporary poets. At the end of the chapter, after a hasty and horrified evening of reading, the Prime Minister chooses to bestow the Laureate on a caricature of Dylan Thomas himself on the basis of a poetic parody that the Prime Minister does not recognize as parody.<\/p>\n<p>The first poem encountered by the Prime Minister is titled &#8220;Lamentable Ode,&#8221; by &#8220;Albert Ponting,&#8221; author of a volume titled &#8220;Claustrophosexannal.&#8221; &#8220;Lamentable Ode&#8221; reads in part:<\/p>\n<blockquote><p>\nThe urge of the purge of the womb of the worm<br \/>\nI renege in the flail-like failing of<br \/>\nThe detumescent sun.<br \/>\nThis my crepuscular palimpsest is:<br \/>\nI am so greatly him that lazarhouses and such<br \/>\nLascivious lodges of the unloved<br \/>\nPeel like pomegranates at my nasal touch<br \/>\nAnd Balham faints in a scalecophidian void. (3)\n<\/p><\/blockquote>\n<p>This was a sesquipedalian smack at Surrealism. The particular Surrealist poet lampooned might be David Gascoyne, whom Thomas had also mocked in his poem &#8220;A Letter to My Aunt Discussing the Correct Approach to Modern Poetry&#8221;: &#8220;Fie on you, aunt, that you should see \/ No genius in David G.&#8221; (<em>The Poems<\/em> 83). The target might instead (or also) be George Barker, another Surrealist (&#8220;tit-in-the-night whistlers and Barkers&#8221;), whose 1937 <em>Calamiterror<\/em> could have inspired the portmanteau coinage &#8220;Claustrophosexannal.&#8221;<\/p>\n<p>Too-Celtic imitators of Yeats are swatted with a deft hand, and patriotic poets are spattered across the windshield in a poem called &#8220;All Honour and Glory,&#8221; which ends in a paean to &#8220;English dawns, plashy with English dew, \/ And English water-wagtails on English lawns, \/ And Englishmen walking in the English way \/ In England &#8230;&#8221; (18).\uffa0Wystan Hugh Auden the inveterate <em>pasticheur<\/em> becomes &#8220;Wyndham Nils Snowden,&#8221; the author of a volume that &#8220;seemed to consist of a series of conversations; or rather, a series of lectures. They were all addressed to other, dead, writers. There was a long squabble with a tongue-tied Spenser in the metre of the <em>Faerie Queene<\/em>; a rap on the knuckles for Scott in the metre of <em>Marmion<\/em>&#8221; (9). T. S. Eliot is let off more lightly in a parody of &#8220;The Hollow Men&#8221; titled &#8220;West Abelard&#8221; that includes the lines &#8220;Even the end is similar. It ends \/ and there&#8217;s an end,&#8221; concluding &#8220;It is not different and it is better \/ that so it should be. \/ Everything is the same&#8221; (16). Even the dim Prime Minister is moved by this: &#8220;He felt queerly depressed, and reached once more for the brandy. [&#8230;] That <em>was<\/em> a lugubrious poem; and the trouble was that it was true. Everything <em>was<\/em> the same. Dull, too. But it would never do to tell them so&#8221; (17).<\/p>\n<p>Of Stephen Spender&#8217;s war poetry, described as a bit &#8220;red&#8221; by the Prime Minister&#8217;s secretary, the Prime Minister wonders, &#8220;What did red mean? Surely that adolescent indignation wasn&#8217;t so very alarming? The poems were full of gasworks and power stations, and bewildered boys&#8221; (13). A representative stanza from the Spender parody, titled &#8220;The Parachutist,&#8221; describes with idiotically saturated sympathy a German soldier who has just parachuted into England:<\/p>\n<blockquote><p>\nNow these once loving-kindly hands<br \/>\nCherished, like an adder picked up on a walk,<br \/>\nA tommy gun, cold threat to love in steel:<br \/>\nIcarus he stands; his silken clouds of glory<br \/>\nTrailing behind him&#8211;a bird&#8217;s broken wing&#8211;<br \/>\nStill trembling from his fallen angel&#8217;s flight<br \/>\nDown the sky weeping death. (14)\n<\/p><\/blockquote>\n<p>Andrew Lycett, the author of <em>Dylan Thomas: A New Life<\/em> (2004), describes young Oxford&#8217;s reaction to this parody:<\/p>\n<blockquote><p>\nAt the start of the Second World War, Oxford poets such as Sidney Keyes regarded Dylan Thomas as a welcome antidote to Auden and his circle. They invited him to address the University English Club, an undergraduate society, in November 1941. Thomas had been working with John Davenport on a novel, <em>The Death of the King&#8217;s Canary,<\/em> which interwove an unlikely story about the murder of the poet laureate with brilliant parodies of contemporary poets. Philip Larkin noted appreciatively: &#8220;Hell of a fine man: little, snubby, hopelessly pissed bloke who made hundreds of cracks and read parodies of everybody in appropriate voices. He remarked, &#8216;I&#8217;d like to have talked about a book of poems I&#8217;ve been given to review, a young poet called Rupert Brooke&#8211;it&#8217;s surprising how he has been influenced by Stephen Spender.&#8217; There was a moment of delighted surprise, then a roar of laughter. Then he read a parody of Spender entitled <em>The Parachutist<\/em> which had people rolling on the floor.&#8221; (Lycett)\n<\/p><\/blockquote>\n<p>Thomas&#8217;s parody of Empson, as it turned out, was the only part of <em>The Death of the King&#8217;s Canary<\/em> to be published in Thomas&#8217;s lifetime; it appeared in the journal <em>Horizon<\/em> in 1942 with the epigraph &#8220;Homage to William Empson.&#8221; Titled &#8220;Request to Leda,&#8221; the poem parodies Empson&#8217;s most immediately recognizable poetic traits: his semantic opacity, his predilection for scientific images and vocabulary, and his affection for the villanelle:<\/p>\n<blockquote><p>\nNot your winged lust but his must now change suit.<br \/>\nThe harp-waked Casanova rakes no range.<br \/>\nThe worm is (pin-point) rational in the fruit.<\/p>\n<p>Not girl for bird (gourd being man) breaks root.<br \/>\nTaking no plume for index in love&#8217;s change.<br \/>\nNot your winged lust but his must now change suit.<\/p>\n<p>Desire is phosphorous: the chemic bruit<br \/>\nLust bears like volts, who&#8217;ll amplify, and strange<br \/>\nThe worm is (pin-point) rational in the fruit.<span id='easy-footnote-1-183' class='easy-footnote-margin-adjust'><\/span><span class='easy-footnote'><a href='https:\/\/villanelle.amandafrench.net\/?page_id=183#easy-footnote-bottom-1-183' title='Text taken from &lt;em&gt;Horizon&lt;\/em&gt; 5.30 (1942): 6.'><sup>1<\/sup><\/a><\/span>\n<\/p><\/blockquote>\n<p>&#8220;Was it the brandy or was he losing his reason?&#8221; thinks the hapless Prime Minister after reading &#8220;Request to Leda.&#8221; &#8220;He had always been terrified of going out of his mind. It had happened to so many of his colleagues. He concentrated hard, but it was no good: the rest of the poem was just as obscure. It looked clear enough, too&#8221; (19).<\/p>\n<p>Bereft of the Prime Minister&#8217;s gloss and of the aggregate hilarity of the other verse parodies in <em>The Death of the King&#8217;s Canary<\/em>, the poem as published in <em>Horizon<\/em> loses much of its comic power. No doubt the &#8220;appropriate voices&#8221; that Thomas adopted in live readings were also necessary to appreciate the parody fully. Read thus out of context, it might even be difficult to recognize &#8220;Request to Leda&#8221; as a parody. Thomas&#8217;s own early poetry, like Empson&#8217;s, had been open to the charge of obscurity; Stephen Spender wrote that Thomas&#8217;s early work had seemed to be that of &#8220;another &#8216;opaque&#8217; poet&#8221;; a reviewer of the first book-length study on Thomas asserted that obscurity was Thomas&#8217;s &#8220;most obvious quality&#8221;; and a school friend of Thomas&#8217;s described his early work as &#8220;verse of the kind which many people can&#8217;t understand&#8221; (qtd. in Davies 295, 296, 19). The first stanza of &#8220;I fellowed sleep,&#8221; from Thomas&#8217;s first book, <em>18 Poems<\/em> (1934), may illustrate this quality:<\/p>\n<blockquote><p>\nI fellowed sleep who kissed me in the brain,<br \/>\nLet fall the tear of time; the sleeper&#8217;s eye,<br \/>\nShifting to light, turned on me like a moon.<br \/>\nSo, &#8216;planing-heeled, I flew along my man<br \/>\nAnd dropped on dreaming and the upward sky.\n<\/p><\/blockquote>\n<p>Thomas&#8217;s mechanical imagery in early poems such as &#8220;The force that through the green fuse drives the flower&#8221; and &#8220;When once the twilight locks no longer,&#8221; too, parallels Empson&#8217;s scientific vocabularies as well as Spender&#8217;s &#8220;gasworks and power stations&#8221;; all were attempts to introduce metaphors of technologized modernity into poetry. Karl Miller notes of Thomas and Empson, &#8220;I believe that I now see resemblances between the two of them (say, between the <em>Eighteen Poems<\/em> and an Empson poem like &#8216;The Scales&#8217;) which I was not aware of in the forties, my frantic youth, when Thomas seemed a working-class Dionysus come out of the West and Empson seemed like the ancient universities&#8221; (Gill 43).<\/p>\n<p>The resemblance between Empson&#8217;s poetry and Thomas&#8217;s may have been a case of direct influence, in fact. One prominent word in Empson&#8217;s &#8220;Villanelle&#8221; of 1928 is the unusual adjective &#8220;chemic,&#8221; which Thomas repeats in the 1942 &#8220;Request to Leda&#8221;&#8211;another arrow aimed at the recognizable target. But a 1934 piece by Thomas, &#8220;Especially when the October wind,&#8221; had used the word &#8220;chemic&#8221; unironically in its final stanza:<\/p>\n<blockquote><p>\nEspecially when the October wind<br \/>\n(Some let me make you of autumnal spells,<br \/>\nThe spider-tongued, and the loud hill of Wales)<br \/>\nWith fists of turnips punishes the land,<br \/>\nSome let me make of you the heartless words.<br \/>\nThe heart is drained that, spelling in the scurry<br \/>\nOf chemic blood, warned of the coming fury.<br \/>\nBy the sea&#8217;s side hear the dark-vowelled birds. (<em>Collected<\/em> 19)\n<\/p><\/blockquote>\n<p>In Empson&#8217;s &#8220;Villanelle,&#8221; the word had been used in the first stanza: &#8220;It is the pain, it is the pain, endures. \/ Your chemic beauty burned my muscles through. \/ Poise of my hands reminded me of yours&#8221; (<em>Collected<\/em> 22). Thomas probably would not have seen &#8220;Villanelle&#8221; when it was first printed in the <em>Cambridge Review<\/em>, but Empson&#8217;s first villanelle had also appeared in at least two well-known anthologies before Thomas&#8217;s poem appeared: <em>Cambridge Poetry 1929<\/em> (1929) and <em>Recent Poetry 1923-1933<\/em> (1933).<span id='easy-footnote-2-183' class='easy-footnote-margin-adjust'><\/span><span class='easy-footnote'><a href='https:\/\/villanelle.amandafrench.net\/?page_id=183#easy-footnote-bottom-2-183' title='Christopher Saltmarshe, John Davenport, and Basil Wright, eds., &lt;em&gt;Cambridge Poetry 1929&lt;\/em&gt; (London: Hogarth, 1929) and Alida Klemantaski Monro, ed., &lt;em&gt;Recent Poetry 1923-1933&lt;\/em&gt; (London: Gerald Howe and The Poetry Bookshop, 1933).'><sup>2<\/sup><\/a><\/span> Both Empson and Thomas seem to be using the word in several senses at once, like good disciples of ambiguity. The primary sense for Empson seems to be &#8220;harsh substance,&#8221; however. His love&#8217;s beauty burns through muscle. The <em>Oxford English Dictionary<\/em> tells us that &#8220;chemic&#8221; is the name given to both &#8220;A bleacher&#8217;s name for chloride of lime as a chemical bleaching agent&#8221; and &#8220;A dye consisting of a very acid solution of indigo in sulphuric acid.&#8221; The <em>OED<\/em> tells us that the word can also refer both to alchemy and to chemistry, the alchemical and the chemical, and both the ancient and the modern transmutative connotations are probably at work in both &#8220;Villanelle&#8221; and &#8220;Especially when the October wind&#8221;&#8211;though Thomas&#8217;s choice of the word &#8220;chemic&#8221; seems less grounded in phenomenal, observed reality than Empson&#8217;s, which may be another indicator that it is a borrowed word.<\/p>\n<p>According to Constantine Fitzgibbon&#8217;s introduction to <em>The Death of the King&#8217;s Canary<\/em>, &#8220;Dylan Thomas maintained that Davenport had written most of the verse parodies. This may well be untrue, for if Dylan was not proud of them, he would have given their authorship to John. Others have said that their skill is far beyond what were Davenport&#8217;s capacities&#8221; (x). Obviously the Empson parody was Thomas&#8217;s, since he published it; he did also lay claim at least once to &#8220;The Parachutist,&#8221; as we have seen. Thomas might well have later denied authorship of the verse parodies in <em>The Death of the King&#8217;s Canary<\/em> not because they were bad, but because they were a little too good. It may be that his clear-sighted recognition of the faults of his contemporaries was matched with a too-clear recognition that his own verse too often shared many of the same faults, and this comparison would undoubtedly have contributed to the lyrical paralysis Thomas notoriously suffered from, especially after 1945. Empson was not the only poet whose work may have seemed too close to Thomas&#8217;s own. The Surrealist parody &#8220;Lamentable Ode,&#8221; for instance, makes heavy use of alliteration, internal rhyme, and consonance, piling comically excessive sound effects one upon the other in phrases such as &#8220;flail-like failing&#8221; and &#8220;The urge of the purge of the womb of the worm.&#8221; To a lesser extent Thomas&#8217;s own poetry&#8211;often equally baffling, semantically&#8211;depended on such acoustic elements for much of its power. &#8220;Womb of the worm,&#8221; moreover, is a particularly Thomasish phrase; the word &#8220;womb&#8221; recurs so frequently in Thomas&#8217;s poetry that detractors have characterized him as the &#8220;womb and tomb&#8221; poet.<\/p>\n<p>That Thomas used the villanelle to parody Empson is not at all remarkable; it was perfectly in keeping with his wild-child &#8220;welcome antidote&#8221; role. What is more surprising, or ought to be, is that Thomas returned to the form unironically. Thomas was clearly not as different from the poets he satirized in <em>The Death of the King&#8217;s Canary<\/em> as he might have wished, and he may have begun to realize it by 1951. &#8220;Do not go gentle into that good night&#8221; also indicates that Thomas, like Empson and Auden, regarded the form in the abstract, separate from any acquired connotation. The villanelle&#8217;s associations with Parnassian prosodic rivalries, France and Frenchness, queer sexualities, chivalric values, moonlight and maidens, the na&iuml;ve, the decadent, the trifling had lost their power, and even the villanelle&#8217;s new character as a risible foible of Empson&#8217;s did not last.<\/p>\n<hr size=\"1\" \/>\n","protected":false},"excerpt":{"rendered":"<p>Dylan Thomas&#8217;s first villanelle&#8211;his only other villanelle besides &#8220;Do not go gentle into that good night&#8221;&#8211;was a parody of William Empson titled &#8220;Request to Leda,&#8221; composed for a novel titled The Death of the King&#8217;s Canary. Like Auden and Empson, Thomas and Empson were friends; in 1936 the twenty-one-year-old Thomas was having &#8220;Nights Out&#8221; with [&hellip;]<\/p>\n","protected":false},"author":3,"featured_media":0,"parent":177,"menu_order":2,"comment_status":"open","ping_status":"open","template":"","meta":{"footnotes":""},"class_list":["post-183","page","type-page","status-publish","hentry"],"_links":{"self":[{"href":"https:\/\/villanelle.amandafrench.net\/index.php?rest_route=\/wp\/v2\/pages\/183","targetHints":{"allow":["GET"]}}],"collection":[{"href":"https:\/\/villanelle.amandafrench.net\/index.php?rest_route=\/wp\/v2\/pages"}],"about":[{"href":"https:\/\/villanelle.amandafrench.net\/index.php?rest_route=\/wp\/v2\/types\/page"}],"author":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/villanelle.amandafrench.net\/index.php?rest_route=\/wp\/v2\/users\/3"}],"replies":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/villanelle.amandafrench.net\/index.php?rest_route=%2Fwp%2Fv2%2Fcomments&post=183"}],"version-history":[{"count":8,"href":"https:\/\/villanelle.amandafrench.net\/index.php?rest_route=\/wp\/v2\/pages\/183\/revisions"}],"predecessor-version":[{"id":815,"href":"https:\/\/villanelle.amandafrench.net\/index.php?rest_route=\/wp\/v2\/pages\/183\/revisions\/815"}],"up":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/villanelle.amandafrench.net\/index.php?rest_route=\/wp\/v2\/pages\/177"}],"wp:attachment":[{"href":"https:\/\/villanelle.amandafrench.net\/index.php?rest_route=%2Fwp%2Fv2%2Fmedia&parent=183"}],"curies":[{"name":"wp","href":"https:\/\/api.w.org\/{rel}","templated":true}]}}